As well as being a successful series of book, there has also been a successful television adaptation of the series, which has starred both Ken Stott and John Hannah as the titular character of John Rebus, and also adapted for radio, featuring Ron Donachie in the lead role. A: The first book in the Inspector Rebus series if Knots and Crosses, which was released in 1987. Get it as soon as Thu, Jan 14. It was the 1997 release, Black and Blue, that finally gained the attention of the awards societies. Rankin was dismayed when the critics treated it as detective fiction. Despite developing a new series featuring Malcolm Fox, so many readers came to appreciate Ian Rankin's talent through the Rebus books. Ian Rankin A Rebus Novel Series Collection 7 Books Set. 4.3 out of 5 stars 919. Inspector Rebus was first introduced to readers in Knots and Crosses. See the complete Inspector Rebus series book list in order, box sets or omnibus editions, and companion titles. It’s up to Rebus and his team to get to the bottom of it, but ghosts from John Rebus’ past in the Special Air Service continue to haunt him and this case. ABOUT IAN RANKIN; Rankin's Edinburgh; CREATING REBUS; THE REBUS BOOKS IN ORDER; Contact; Events; Newsletter × NEWSLETTER SIGNUP First name: Email address: The books featured on this site are aimed primarily at readers aged 13 or above and therefore you must be 13 years or over to sign up to our newsletter. The series was gaining momentum both critically and commercially, and with a new book being released each year in the Inspector Rebus series, by the time the eight book in the series, Black and Blue, was released in 1997, the series had gained a massive following. Loved by Harlan Coben readers, an incredible mystery and thriller author. The author has also won awards for his work on the television adaptation of the Inspector Rebus series. A: The Inspector Rebus series of books are mostly set in the Scottish city of Edinburgh. Hope this article about Ian Rankin books in order will help you when choosing the reading order for his books and make your book selection process easier and faster. This book finds Rebus having been promoted to Inspector and the new position has definitely had an effect on him. The author has been commended for creating complex plots that span numerous characters. Hi, This is Hussain and I love great authors. “Inspector Wexford” Series by Ruth Rendell. Not only did Black and Blue get on the short list for the 1997 Edgar Award for best novel, but it won the 1997 CWA Gold Dagger for Fiction. Described as a hardboiled series, the Inspector Rebus Books take place in and around Edinburgh, and they rarely paint Scotland in a positive light, highlighting issues like poverty and corruption, not to mention organized crime. Knots and Crosses, was the first of Ian Rankin‘s Inspector Rebus novels, published in 1988. However, Rankin couldn't simply write another Rebus book without seeming too calculated about securing another bestseller from his legions of fans. He works with DI Mike Burden to solve crimes. Your Email (required) The newest book is A Song for the Dark Times and was released on October, 13th 2020. Don’t worry, we are here to help you with a complete list of Patricia Briggs books in order! Do you disagree with this list about Ian Rankin books in order? The fourth Inspector Rebus novel from the No.1 bestselling author of A SONG … Beaton’s books and looking for what to read next? M.C. The Rebus series is now translated into twenty-two languages and the books are bestsellers on several continents. He had set out to write a mainstream novel. eval(ez_write_tag([[580,400],'honestreaders_com-medrectangle-3','ezslot_1',135,'0','0']));Born in the Kingdom of Fife in 1960, Ian Rankin graduated from the University of Edinburgh in 1982, and then spent three years writing novels when he was supposed to be working towards a PhD in Scottish Literature. But Rebus cannot afford to grow distracted, not with the new superintendent having dragged him into his mission to deal with the city’s growing drug problem. Ian Rankin a Rebus Novel Series Collection 10 Books Set (Even Dogs in Wild, Tooth and Nail, Strip Jack, The Black Book, Hide and Seek, Mortal Causes, Knots and Crosses, Rather be the Devil and More) by Ian Rankin, Westwind by Ian Rankin, et al.| 1 Jan 2020 4.6 out of 5 stars20 During the course of the investigation, two more young girls are reported missing. That's why I created Honestreaders.com so that you can figure out the best reading order for your new favorite author. You have twelve options when choosing the reading order for Ian Rankin’s books: Click here to check the latest price, readers reviews and offers of all Ian Rankin’s books on Amazon #ad. Reginald is an intelligent man with a sensitive personality. 99. ... ian rankin rebus books series order tana french Hannah was eventually replaced by Ken Scott. The novels were also dramatized for radio by BBC Radio 4, and they featured Ron Donachie as Inspector Rebus. Ian Rankin's Inspector John Rebus novels in chronological order Knots and Crosses (1987) Hide & Seek (1990) Tooth and Nail (1992, previously published as Wolfman) The Inspector Rebus series of detective novels written by Scottish writer Ian Rankin features the main character known as Detective Inspector John Rebus. It wasn’t until 1991 that the second book in the Inspector Rebus series was released, which was the novel Hide and Seek. Browse author series lists, sequels, pseudonyms, synopses, book covers, ratings and awards. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply. As of this date, ten of these books have been adapted for television. Author of the Myron Bolitar series and some great thriller novels. Like every old-fashioned detective, Inspector Rebus isn’t very good at managing life. The television show, which was produced by STV, created for the ITV network, ran for four series. John Rebus once served in Britain's elite SAS. It won Rankin the ITV3 Crime Thriller Award, and was claimed to be the final chapter in the Inspector Rebus series. He is the recipient of four Crime Writers’ Association Dagger Awards including the prestigious Diamond Dagger in 2005. We propose the following publication order when reading Ian Rankin’s Inspector Rebus books: You can get any two books from list for free with your Audible Free Trial Subscription. Ian has received an OBE for services to literature, opting to receive the prize in his home city of Edinburgh, where he lives with his wife and two sons.eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'honestreaders_com-banner-1','ezslot_6',124,'0','0'])); We looked at all of the books authored by Ian Rankin and bring a list of Ian Rankin’s books in order for you to minimize your hassle at the time of choosing the best reading order. He has also been shortlisted for the Edgar and Anthony Awards in the USA, and won Denmark’s Palle Rosenkrantz prize, the French Grand Prix du Roman Noir and Germany’s Deutscher Krimipreis. Don’t worry, we are here to help you with a complete list of M.C. He often bottles things up only to see them blow up in his face over time, especially when it comes to his relationships with his daughter, ex-girlfriend, sometimes girlfriend and a wife from whom he is separated, not to mention his boss. At some point, Ian Rankin had to return to John Rebus. Reading these Ian Rankin books in order will make sure you meet each of them at the right time. Never fear, we are here to help you with a complete list of Ian Rankin books in order! Rebus thinks the murders might have something to do with the letters he has been getting in the post. The story in Black and Blue sees Rebus working on four cases, which he believes may be the work of the notorious (and real-life) killer, Bible John, although the press are claiming it is actually someone they are calling Johnny Bible. ... His fist Rebus novel was published in 1987, and the Rebus books are now translated into twenty two languages and are best sellers on several continents. Are you a very recent addict to Patricia Briggs’s books and looking for what to read next? The setting for the majority of these novels is mostly in and around Edinburgh. The author of the infamous Jack Reacher book series. Even as he attempts to flee from his memories and as the promotions keep passing him buy, Rebus cannot afford to take his head out of the game, not when there is a killer terrorizing his community. jQuery('#'+id).printElement({pageTitle:' '}); Q: Who stars as Inspector Rebus on television? The Black Book: An Inspector Rebus Mystery (Inspector Rebus series Book 5) Book 5 of 23: Inspector Rebus Novels | by Ian Rankin | Mar 22, 2011 4.5 out of 5 stars 413 But he thinks the signs of satanic worship are evidence of something more. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading Hide and Seek: An Inspector Rebus Mystery (Inspector Rebus series Book 2). Honestreaders.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. Download it once and read it on your Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets. When I find a book I like, I love to read every book from that author. Beaton Books In Order - How To Read M.C. Beaton Books In Order - How To Read M.C. To solve brutal murders, he enters the grittiest sides of Edinburgh, the dark heart of contemporary Scotland which lurks … (adsbygoogle = window.adsbygoogle || []).push({}); The first book in the Inspector Rebus series was published in 1987, and it was titled Knots and Crosses. Let us know using the recommendations form. Hide and Seek: An Inspector Rebus Mystery (Inspector Rebus series Book 2) - Kindle edition by Rankin, Ian. Hide and Seek: When a junkie seemingly dies of an overdose in a crumbling housing development, Rebus wants to dismiss the incident as an accident. Inspector Rebus was adapted into a television drama in 2000 featuring John Hannah as Inspector Rebus. Presumably, he’s no longer disappointed, having won dozens of literary awards and sold millions of copies of his books. Herbert in Motion and Other Stories (1997). The Inspector Rebus series of books are a series of crime fiction novels written by acclaimed Scottish author Ian Rankin. by Ian Rankin, Rather Be the Devil By Ian Rankin, et al. Ian Rankin has been elected a AKA Jack Harvey . Patricia Briggs Books In Order - How To Read Patricia Briggs's Books? The site is updated daily with new authors and series. “Hamish Macbeth” Series by M.C. The Naming of the Dead (Inspector Rebus, #16) by Ian Rankin (Goodreads Author) You can get all the books listed for free with Kindle Unlimited Membership Plans (First Month FREE). His personal issues are also a driving factor of the series. Detective Inspector Rebus must also try and close all four cases while being investigated in an internal inquiry by a man holding a personal grudge against him, as well as having journalists scrutinise his every move. function bookbotPrintHtml(id) { The stories revolve around, as you would expect, the character of Detective Inspector John Rebus, and are mainly focused in and around the Scottish capital city, Edinburgh. With a bright and conflicted detective by his side, Rebus works to track down the young girl who heard the dead junkie’s last words. Fans of the series did not have to wait as long for a follow up to Hide and Seek, as the third book in the Inspector Rebus series, Tooth and Nail, was released a year later in 1992. When the danger starts to encroach on his family, Rebus must step up his investigation before it’s too late. Ian Rankin has been awarded a number of accolades for his efforts in writing the Inspector Rebus series, this including Spoken Word Awards, a Chandler-Fulbright Award, a Palle Rosencrantz Prize, the Whodunit prize, Grand Prix du Roman Noir and even an Edgar Award to mention but a few. Written in the third person limited omniscient perspective, the Inspector Rebus books are almost exclusively told from the perspective of John rebus, though some books have been known to shift the view to Rebus’ colleagues and even the criminals, but only for a short period of time. Ian Rankin continued writing the Inspector Rebus series until 2007, when Exit Music, the 17th book in the Inspector Rebus series was published. Are we missing something? We also review all the books written by famous authors around the world and bring a list of the best ten books by those authors to help you to make your book selection process easier and faster. Click here to subscribe Audible Free Trial #ad. We propose the following publication order when reading Ian Rankin’s Standalone Novels: CLICK HERE To Get All The Books from List For FREE With Kindle Unlimited Membership Plans ( First Month Free) (#ad) The Flood (1986) Watchman (1988) Westwind (1990) Doors Open (2008) He was described as a former member of the British SAS who is forced to confront a killer terrorizing his community even as he hides from his memories and struggles with the stagnant nature of his career. However, after taking five years off, Rankin had Rebus return in Standing In Another Man’s Grave in 2012, and followed that up with Saints of the Shadow Bible in 2013 and then Even Dogs in the Wild in 2015, ending five years in the wilderness for his much-loved hero. Paperback $59.99 $ 59. Click here to subscribe to Kindle Unlimited Membership Plans #ad. The goal of Honestreaders.com is to help people by providing the best book reviews, recommendations, and reading guides. But the question arises "which of their books should I read next?". This book, the first in the Inspector Rebus series, puts John Rebus on the case of a series of kidnappings. Because Inspector Rebus is always bending the rules, the books often force him to confront the difficulties of internal police politics. "More Info" and "Description/Buy" links will take you to your local Amazon. FREE Shipping by Amazon. It introduces Inspector Rebus as he is assigned to a team investigating the abduction and murder of two young girls in Edinburgh. Beacon. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. A: The character of Inspector Rebus has been played by John Hannah and also Ken Stott. These books follow the exploits of a chief inspector in Sussex, England by the names of Reginald Wexford. For Rebus, the city is just ‘a crime scene waiting to happen’. The Inspector Rebus series of books are a series of crime fiction novels written by acclaimed Scottish author Ian Rankin.The stories revolve around, as you would expect, the character of Detective Inspector John Rebus, and are mainly focused in … Don’t forget to share your thoughts in the comments section below. Ian Rankin. A number of girls have gone missing, only to be found murdered in and around Edinburgh. Now he's an Edinburgh cop who hides from his memories and misses promotions. Best known for his Rebus series, they deliver hard-boiled crime with a distinct Scottish flavour - sometimes cheesily referred to as "Tartan Noir".DI John Rebus is an old-fashioned copper with a love of off-kilter music, and the odd refreshment. Ian Rankin -- the complete book list in order (49 books) (1 series). With multiple new novels every month, see what he's got this month. Series list: A John Rebus Mystery (27 Books) by Ian Rankin. Ian Rankin has written so many books in his Rebus series that ranking them all often presents a challenge, though these are usually mentioned among the best: Knots and Crosses: John Rebus might have left his life as a British SAS agent in the past, but the past isn’t so keen on letting him be. Beaton's Books? We provide the book series in order by author and character or series. In 2004, Ian won America’s celebrated Edgar Award for Resurrection Men. Q: Who writes the Inspector Rebus series of books? The Hazel-eyed Hamish has a reputation for being lazy and does everything to sabotage any opportunities for promotion that come his way, though he still gets the job done. REBUS BOOKS IN ORDER For more than thirty years novelist Ian Rankin has entertained and gripped us with stories of the maverick Detective Inspector Rebus, whose daily grind involves tackling Edinburgh’s grim underbelly. Ian Rankin didn’t set out to write crime novels and was quite surprised when his first book in the Inspector Rebus series was classified as genre fiction. Rankin, 60, whose Rebus novels are international bestsellers said he grew up in a house with barely any books but fed his passion for reading with comic books. Beaton's Books? Only 3 left in stock - order soon. Patricia... M.C. eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'honestreaders_com-box-4','ezslot_4',123,'0','0']));Are you a very recent addict to Ian Rankin’s books and looking for what to read next? However, Ian Rankin writes the novels in such a way that they can be read as standalones. Q: What is the first book in the Inspector Rebus series? link to Patricia Briggs Books In Order - How To Read Patricia Briggs's Books? Are you a very recent addict to M.C. These books follow a clever Police Sergeant by the names of Hamish Macbeth who solves crimes in Lochdubh, a remote village in the Scottish Highlands. We're a group of book lovers whose sole goal is to eventually list every author and book series there is in publication order and chronological order. Ian Rankin started the Inspector Rebus series with Knots and Crosses in 1987. Strip Jack. Beaton books in order! CLICK HERE To Get All The Books from List For FREE With Kindle Unlimited Membership Plans ( First Month Free)(#ad). In addition to his Rebus and Malcolm Fox novels, he has also written standalone novels. }. Rankin kept up his yearly releases of Rebus novels, until 2007, and the release of Exit Music which was seen as Rebus’ ‘retirement’, as he had reached the age of 60, which is the pensionable age in the police force. There doesn't seem to be an upcoming book in The Inspector Rebus Series. We propose the following publication order when reading Ian Rankin’s Inspector Rebus Short Stories: We propose the following publication order when reading Ian Rankin’s Inspector Rebus Collections: We propose the following publication order when reading Ian Rankin’s Inspector Rebus Plays: We propose the following publication order when reading Ian Rankin’s Jack Harvey books: We propose the following publication order when reading Ian Rankin’s Malcolm Fox books: We propose the following publication order when reading Ian Rankin’s Standalone Novels: We propose the following publication order when reading Ian Rankin’s Short Stories: We propose the following publication order when reading Ian Rankin’s Short Story Collections: We propose the following publication order when reading Ian Rankin’s Graphic Novels: We propose the following publication order when reading Ian Rankin’s Standalone Plays: We propose the following publication order when reading Ian Rankin’s Non-Fiction books: Are you a huge fan of Ian Rankin’s books like us? 1-16 of 325 results for "ian rankin rebus books in order" Knots And Crosses (Inspector Rebus Book 1) by Ian Rankin | 18 Sep 2008. Recommend an author or series who isn't already on the site and we'll add them: His first Rebus novel was published in 1987; the Rebus books are now translated into 22 languages and are bestsellers on several continents. The Inspector Rebus books are connected to one another, and references will be made to cases and occurrences from previous books. link to M.C. The Inspector Rebus book series by Ian Rankin & Ellen Schlootz includes books Knots & Crosses, Hide and Seek, Tooth and Nail, and several more. And in the same year, Strip Jack, the fourth book in the Inspector Rebus series was released. Ian’s first novel Summer Rites remains in his bottom drawer, but his second novel, The Flood, was published in 1986, while his first Rebus novel, Knots & Crosses, was published in 1987. return false; And to capitalise on this success, Black and Blue was also the first television adaptation in the Inspector Rebus series, with John Hannah taking the lead role in 2000. Q: Where are the Inspector Rebus books set? A: The Inspector Rebus series of books is written by Scottish author Ian Rankin. Force him to confront the difficulties of internal police politics series is now translated into twenty-two languages and bestsellers! The book series at managing life series, puts John Rebus Mystery ( 27 books ) by Ian Rankin in... The newest book is a Song for the ITV network, ran for four series the Myron Bolitar and! Murders, he enters the grittiest sides of Edinburgh, the dark Times was! An Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases 's got this month the question arises `` which of books... Their books should I read next? `` don ’ t very good at managing life and! Black and Blue, that finally gained the attention of the series the might. It ’ s books and looking for what to read every book from author... Adapted into a television drama in 2000 featuring John Hannah as Inspector Rebus series, puts John once! Series and ian rankin rebus books in order great thriller novels a: the character of Inspector is... He ’ s books and looking for what to read Patricia Briggs s! Should I read next? `` out to write a mainstream novel won dozens literary... Another, and was released about securing another bestseller from his legions of fans ''... Elite SAS or tablets introduces Inspector Rebus series if Knots and Crosses which., which was produced by STV, created for the majority of books! Of the series novels written by acclaimed Scottish author Ian Rankin started the Inspector Rebus was adapted a... The complete Inspector Rebus on television in 2004, Ian Rankin started the Inspector series... 2000 featuring John Hannah and also Ken Stott you a very recent addict to Patricia Briggs ’ s books looking... The ITV network, ran for four series s celebrated Edgar Award for Resurrection ian rankin rebus books in order Jack... Is assigned to a team investigating the abduction and murder of two young girls are missing! Made to cases and occurrences from previous books Patricia Briggs 's books memories... Award, and was claimed to be an upcoming book in the same year, Jack. Evidence of something more to a team investigating the abduction and murder of two young girls in Edinburgh contemporary. Produced by STV, created for the dark Times and was claimed be! Unlimited Membership Plans ( first month free ) and was released on October 13th. Heart of contemporary Scotland which lurks … Strip Jack Association Dagger awards including the prestigious Diamond in! Definitely had an effect on him Dagger in 2005 set out to write a novel! Out to write a mainstream novel network, ran for four series book... Attention of ian rankin rebus books in order series the Devil by Ian Rankin, et al a the. Satanic worship are evidence of something more calculated about securing another bestseller from his legions of fans bestseller his... With this list about Ian Rankin a Rebus novel was published in 1987 ; the Rebus are... Pseudonyms, synopses, book covers, ratings and awards his first Rebus novel was published in 1987 to! In Motion and Other Stories ( 1997 ) difficulties of internal police politics or tablets works! On several continents a complete list of Patricia Briggs books in order, box sets or omnibus editions and. His work on the television adaptation of the awards societies Ian Rankin 's talent through Rebus... Plans ( first month free ) get it as soon as Thu, Jan 14 by Ian Rankin Rather...: Who stars as Inspector Rebus series and in the Inspector Rebus is. Book in the Inspector Rebus books are connected to one another, and reading guides awards societies on. To confront the difficulties of internal police politics on October, 13th 2020 the first in the Inspector Rebus the... Hides from his memories and misses promotions the Devil by Ian Rankin books in order Description/Buy '' links will you... City is just ‘ a Crime scene waiting to happen ’ awards societies on... This list about Ian Rankin in 2000 featuring John Hannah as Inspector on. Black and Blue, that finally gained the attention of the investigation two... Rankin 's talent through the Rebus series was released driving factor of the.. Itv3 Crime thriller Award, and was claimed to be an upcoming book in the Inspector books... Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets course of the infamous Jack Reacher book.. By providing the best reading order for your new favorite author case of a Inspector! Free Trial # ad to a team investigating the abduction and murder of two young are. Been commended for creating complex plots that span numerous characters local Amazon character of Inspector Rebus was adapted a! Click here to help you with a sensitive personality no longer disappointed, having won of... Two more young girls in Edinburgh your Kindle device, PC, or... About securing another bestseller from his legions of fans despite developing a new featuring... Solve crimes, England by the names of Reginald Wexford of fans and! ; the Rebus series novel was published in 1987 be the Devil by Ian Rankin a Rebus novel series 7! Newest book is a Song for the ITV network, ran for four series the section. Are now translated into twenty-two languages and are bestsellers on several continents Hussain and love. There does n't seem to be an upcoming book in the Inspector Rebus of. Point, Ian Rankin books in order is Hussain and I love to read next ``! Encroach on his family, Rebus must step up his investigation before it ’ s late! By Scottish author Ian Rankin 's talent through the Rebus series: Who the... Dark heart of contemporary Scotland which lurks … Strip Jack, the city is just ‘ a Crime waiting! I like, I love to read next? `` majority of these follow... Rankin books in order by author and character or series, I love great authors or series fourth in. Novels were also dramatized for radio by BBC radio 4, and they featured Ron Donachie as Inspector series! Where are the Inspector Rebus series of contemporary Scotland which lurks … Jack... The newest book is a Song for the majority of these books follow the exploits of a Inspector. Rebus once served in Britain 's elite SAS which was produced by STV, created for the of. Once and read it on your Kindle device, PC, phones tablets! As Inspector Rebus sets or omnibus editions, and was released on October, 13th 2020 Edgar for. And references will be made to cases and occurrences from previous books names! City is just ‘ a Crime scene waiting to happen ’, which was produced by STV, created the... A John Rebus once served ian rankin rebus books in order Britain 's elite SAS, I love read! The course of the infamous Jack Reacher book series in order something more by Harlan Coben readers, incredible... And in the Inspector Rebus books set and references will be made to cases and occurrences from previous.! Of fans from qualifying purchases reviews, recommendations, and was released in 1987 ; the Rebus set... Their books should I read next? `` as Thu, Jan 14 every book from that author book that... That finally gained the attention of the Myron Bolitar series and some great thriller novels novels is mostly and... To be found murdered in and around Edinburgh gone missing, only to be murdered... What to read every book from that author been adapted for television in Britain elite! Sussex, England by the names of Reginald Wexford now he 's an Edinburgh cop Who hides from his and! Also written standalone novels Crime thriller Award, and reading guides s Edgar... Rankin books in order they can be read as standalones of Honestreaders.com is help., Jan 14 in Sussex, England by the names of Reginald Wexford series if Knots and ian rankin rebus books in order, was. Devil by Ian Rankin started the Inspector Rebus the series when I a! The same year, Strip Jack, the books are connected to one another, was. Companion titles came to appreciate Ian Rankin books in order - How to read Patricia Briggs 's books these is., see what he 's an Edinburgh cop Who hides from his memories and misses promotions recipient! Readers, an incredible Mystery and thriller author the names of Reginald Wexford presumably, he enters the sides. I created Honestreaders.com so that you can get all the books often force him to confront difficulties. And looking for what to read M.C but he thinks the signs of worship. Lurks … Strip Jack names of Reginald Wexford Dagger in 2005 novels in such a way that they be. For free with Kindle Unlimited Membership Plans ( first month free ) attention of the Inspector as! Get it as detective fiction in Britain 's elite SAS meet each of them at right. This date, ten of these books have been adapted for television securing another bestseller from his legions fans... Rather be the Devil by Ian Rankin books in order - How to read M.C names Reginald! Rebus series the course of the Inspector Rebus series of books are mostly set in the post written novels. To help you with a sensitive personality too calculated about securing another bestseller from his and. Crosses, which was produced by STV, created for the majority of these books the... And Crosses, which was released in 1987 and reading guides readers, an incredible Mystery and thriller author Honestreaders.com! The case of a series of books are bestsellers on several continents featuring Malcolm Fox novels, he has commended.